Thank you Chancellor Hathaway.
It is a great honor and a pleasure to be here today to share with you
some few thoughts on teaching and learning.
This semester, for the first time in a good many years, I gave my
students testsa mid-term and a final exam. While giving tests
is normal for many teachers, we writing teachers prefer ten pound, fifty
source, two hundred footnote research papers and fat, end-of-semester
portfolios.
The class in which I gave those exams was a big one, a class that spent
the first few weeks of the semester wandering the campus like some Lost
Tribe of Goldilocks in search of a room. Shuffling from place to place,
building to building, this room too hot, this one too big, this one
way too little, we wound up, at last, in an antiquated theater style
classroom with bad lights, hideous purple chairs, not even one left
handed writing surface, and a single small blackboard. About halfway
through the semester, somebody came in and ripped out six or seven rows
of seats and left us staring at rusty spots and bolt holes in the ugly
tile floor, hearing the cavernous echoes of our voices in a now mostly
empty room.
Sometimes education is an adventure.
Still, it was a good semester because, sitting in that strange room,
watching my students sweat through those two exams and then reading
what they had written reminded me that education, even in the most routine
semester is always an adventure. And that reminded me that most of what
we hear and some of what we think about education doesn't tell us very
much about what teachers and students really do when they gather around
a subject to learn.
It is easy, for example, to believe that education is about teachers
giving things to you, our studentsfacts, figures, deep ideas,
answers to life's hard questions. In this way of thinking, teachers
are the great gift givers and students are the gift receivers. But in
fact, in our university, where you are often older, more experienced,
and certainly more dedicated than students in other places, teachers,
if they are open to it, receive as much as they give.
As teachers, we give you our best and dearest friendsPlato, Aristotle,
Mahatma Ghandi, Sojourner Truth, Albert Einstein, Jacque Derrida, Abraham
Lincoln, Marie Curie, Martin Luther King, Virginia Woolf. These friends
of ours, in the words they have written and spoken, give their great
giftsideas, concepts, tools with which to build whatever can be
imagined. They open doors and usher you into places you never dreamed
existed, places that shape, challenge, and change you. In this way,
our gifts root themselves deep into your lives where they grow, multiply,
and will, I promise you, bear great and surprising fruit.
As students, you return our gifts, not a tenth part, but tenfold. You
have given us the magic of one thought connected to another to create
something new in the world. You have given us the pleasure of seeing
your experiments work to the fifth decimal point, the joy of helping
you win a fellowship or a scholarship, and the satisfaction of writing
a recommendation for your perfect job, which you will begin Monday morning.
When you come to our offices so excited about the material we are learning
together that you can't wait until class begins, when your research
papers are as good as the ones that get published in our best journals,
when your essays take our breath away, I tell you, we're like children
on Christmas morning. And someday, years from now, when we read or hear
that you have done some great thing, that you successfully defended
your dissertation or that you were the first choice for that fat promotion,
we'll remember that we once learned together, and in that memory, we
will receive still one more small, precious package.
When such gifts pass back and forth, the lines between teachers and
learners, between teachers and students get blurred. At times they disappear,
and we find ourselves, teachers, students, learners, engaged not in
the simple acts of reading, writing, and arithmetic, but in the complicated
acts of celebrating our differences, dreaming a better world, and negotiating
agreements that allow us to build strong, caring communities in and
out of the classroom. Somewhere along the way, if teaching and learning
work, we come to understand that the giving of such incredible gifts
can happen only in the presence of love and respect. No syllabus or
course description will ever mention this, but all teachers and learners
know that it is the very heart of what we do together.
And here, this morning, in thisdare I say sacred?space,
we, teachers and learners, parents and children, husbands and wives,
faculty and administrators, friends, all of us have converged to give
our greatest giftthe honoring of those who have earned this day.
Graduates, you will soon step up to this small stage, hear your names,
and take your degrees, some of you doctorates, some masters, many more
associates and baccalaureates. When you take that scroll and the hand
of the one who gives it, think for a moment of all you have learned
and all you have taught; think of sacrifice and magic; think of those
whose lives have been and will be changed by who you are, what you know,
and who you will become in the years that lie ahead of you; think of
the work and of the costs; think of those who played a part; and most
of all, think of love and of respect, without which no gift can be given
or received.
As a representative of all the teachers you have taught along your
way to this moment, I congratulate you, and I thank you most sincerely
for allowing us the honor of being a part of this communal celebrating,
dreaming, and negotiating process we call education. May that process
continue through every hour of your lives.